MrT the producer was here most of the day on Friday....we looked over all the music for the new album and did a fair amount of discussing and arguing over some of the songs.
One of my favorite songs to perform is "Call Me Softly" which is on the album "Close Your Eyes" and will be on this one as well; it is a love song with a very classic melody and a powerful message - when you love someone, you want your love to reach across time and space and difficulty to comfort and cherish them, no matter where they are.
Because I wrote this song with a specific situation in mind, I chose to paint a picture... in the first verse, the woman sees the man she loves when he was a child, being abused and treated badly, and she longs to have somehow been there to comfort and hold him, even though she didn't even know him then.
It is an emotion I have often felt about those that I love; when I hear about some way they were mistreated, even if it was long ago, I wish I could have been there, and so that verse was special to me.
*sigh*
However....as MrT pointed out, the first verse doesn't really fit with the second verse, which is much more direct, talking about the man waking in the night thinking he hears her voice, only to discover the bed is empty. He said that is a much more powerful picture, and the other verse must coincide.
I protested that if people saw the video, it would make perfect sense.....but of course, I know, as a songwriter, if you have to explain what the song is about, it isn't a very good song!
At first, this song wasn't going to be on the album at all; we had more than enough material, and this song is already on 'Close Your Eyes'.
But with the sort of sweeping, gorgeous arrangement and production that he does, this song could be so moving, so powerful....neither of us could resist the idea of doing it together.
So I am faced with a re-write.
Re-writes make me nervous! I am always afraid I cannot come up with something that will match the original flow. But in this case, it is especially hard, because the other verse packs such an emotional wallop, I don't know if I can do it again. This song came to me in the middle of the night, I sat straight up in bed and wrote the whole thing down without even pausing, and I'm a little afraid to try to edit. Can I possibly write something that I can
feel when I sing it, the way I do the original?
I guess we'll see.